Best Seller 2 Pack - Choose Your Own

$84.95

Free local pickup

Choose from their 5 iconic flavors to create your perfect pack. Select from: Billionaire's, Millionaire’s, Peanut Butter Cup, Cherry Bakewell, and Rainbow Cookie. Craft your own collection and savor the flavors that have made Shortbread Society legendary. Available in regular and gluten-free (excluding Peanut Butter Cup)!

Each shortbread tray measures 8.6″× 6.1″ × 2″, weighs 2 to 2.5 lbs and serves 8 to 12 people

Ship to me

All sales final

Ingredients

Billionaire’s – Ap Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Dark Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup, Vanilla Extract, Edible Gold Dust & Glitter

Gluten-Free Billionaire’s – King Arthur Gluten-Free Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Dark Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup Vanilla Extract, Edible Gold Dust & Glitter

Cherry Bakewell – Ap Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Vanilla & Almond Extract, Raspberry & Almond Filling, Glacé Cherries, Salt & Water

Gluten-Free Cherry Bakewell - King Arthur Gluten Free Flour, Butter, Sugar, Vanilla & Almond Extract, Raspberry & Almond Filling, Glacé Cherries, Salt & Water

Millionaires – Ap Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Dark Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup & Vanilla Extract

Gluten-Free Millionaires – King Arthur Gluten-Free Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Dark Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup & Vanilla Extract

Millionaire’s (White Chocolate) – Ap Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, White Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup & Vanilla Extract

Gluten-Free Millionaire’s (White Chocolate) – King Arthur Gluten-Free Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, White Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup, Vanilla Extract

Millionaire’s (Milk Chocolate) – AP Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Milk Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup, Vanilla Extract

Gluten-Free Millionaire’s (Milk Chocolate) – King Arthur Gluten-Free Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Milk Chocolate, Condensed Milk, Grapeseed Oil, Golden Syrup, Vanilla Extract

Peanut Butter Cup – Ap Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Milk Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Graham Cracker, Grapeseed Oil, Vanilla Extract & 1 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup

Rainbow Cookie – AP Enriched Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Raspberry & Apricot Fillings, Dark Chocolate, Grapeseed Oil, Almond Essence, Rd & Grn FD Clr, and Rainbow Sprinkles

Gluten-Free Rainbow Cookie – King Arthur Flour, Butter, Sugar, Salt, Raspberry & Apricot Fillings, Dark Chocolate, Grapeseed Oil, Almond Essence, Rd & Grn FD Clr, and Rainbow Sprinkles

Most items are made without Eggs
Produced in a facility that uses nuts and processes all Standard, Vegan, and Gluten Free products using the same equipment

Delivery vs Local Pickup Pricing

Nationwide Delivery via Goldbelly– Pricing includes overnight shipping to anywhere in the U.S., with premium insulated packaging and protective materials to ensure your shortbread arrives in optimal condition.

Local Pickup– Jersey City – Offered at a local rate for in-person pickup by appointment only.

Important Pickup Info

Shortbread Society is a shipping-based business. We are not a brick-and-mortar storefront, and pickups are available by appointment only at our Jersey City location. Lead time for pickup orders is a minimum of 48 hours. At checkout, you will be able to schedule your preferred pickup time. After checkout, you will receive an email with all necessary pickup instructions.

Please arrive promptly at your scheduled pickup time. Due to building security and scheduling constraints, we are unable to accommodate late arrivals. If you are more than 15 minutes late, your order will be forfeited without refund. We kindly ask that you plan accordingly, as late arrivals cannot be accommodated and no exceptions will be made.

Thank you for your understanding and support - we look forward to seeing you!

How to store, slice, and savor your luxurious shortbread creations

Follow these steps to ensure every bite is as fabulous as the first!

Freeze & savor later:

Your shortbread may be refrigerated for up to 2 weeks or frozen for up to 6 months.
Store it in an airtight container to maintain that perfect texture.
Make sure to bring frozen shortbreads back to room temperature prior to slicing.

Best served:

Always serve your shortbread at room temperature for the ultimate experience, and never cut your shortbread cold—it's all about that room temp magic!

Prep:

All shortbreads should be sliced at room temperature.
For chocolate-topped shortbreads, we recommend very lightly chilling for 5-8 minutes in the freezer and removing it from the tin cold to keep that rich chocolate topping intact. Then bring to room temperature to slice.

Tin talk:

For easy slicing and serving, we recommend removing your shortbread from the tin.

Loosen up:

To do so, first take a knife or an offset spatula to score around the edge of the tin to separate the shortbread and filling from the edges of the tin.

Pop & slice:

Gently expand the corners of the tin and pop out the shortbread.

Slice right:

On a flat surface, while using a cutting board, use a sharp knife and slowly slice your shortbread.
Each shortbread tray can serve 8 regular slices or 16+ bite-sized pieces.

Serve and enjoy!